SOVEREIGN COMMENTARY

News, Comment, and Opinion

* * *
A thoughtful compilation and analysis of some important, but underreported and under-researched news stories, with particular focus on keeping the People informed about all Enemies, Foreign and Domestic.

============
BY ALFRED WEST

(AKA THE SOVEREIGN EDITOR).
============
_____________________________________________________________________________
Google
 
Web sovrealm.blogspot.com
_____________________________________________________________________________

RECENT POSTS

  • More on the Deep, Dark Secrets of CAFTA
  • Man Who Commits Sexual Assault on Child Doesn't Ha...
  • The FairTax: A Rebuttal
  • China and Russia to Engage in Joint Military Exerc...
  • Unites States Senator Opposes UN Control of Intern...
  • Viable Alternative Energy: Solar Energy Production...
  • The Tyrants of Beijing will not acquire Unocal
  • A Big Welcome to Anti-UN Ambassador to the UN, Joh...
  • Bush Wants Intelligent Design Taught Along Side Ev...
  • CAFTA Now Law; Congress, President Spit on America...




  • ARCHIVES

    Month:
  • November 2004
  • December 2004
  • January 2005
  • February 2005
  • March 2005
  • April 2005
  • May 2005
  • June 2005
  • July 2005
  • August 2005
  • September 2005
  • October 2005
  • November 2005
  • December 2005
  • January 2006
  • February 2006
  • March 2006
  • April 2006
  • May 2006
  • June 2006
  • July 2006
  • August 2006
  • September 2006
  • October 2006
  • November 2006
  • December 2006
  • January 2007
  • February 2007
  • March 2007
  • April 2007
  • May 2007
  • June 2007
  • July 2007
  • August 2007
  • September 2007
  • October 2007
  • November 2007
  • December 2007

  • Subject Matter:
  • Alternative Energy
  • Asset Forfeiture
  • Astronomy
  • California
  • China
  • Congress
  • Connecticut
  • Constitution
  • Corruption
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Eminent Domain
  • Energy
  • Environmental Concerns
  • Europe
  • European Union
  • Florida
  • France
  • Germany
  • Georgia
  • History
  • Identity Theft
  • Illegal Immigration
  • International Law
  • International Relations
  • Islam
  • Israel
  • Japan
  • Law
  • Liberty
  • Massachusetts
  • Media Bias
  • Medicine
  • Mexico
  • Militant Islam
  • Militaristic Aggression
  • New Jersey
  • North Korea
  • Police State
  • Privacy
  • Rhode Island
  • Russia
  • Science
  • Second Amendment
  • Slavery
  • Social Security
  • Space Exploration
  • Supreme Court
  • Surveillance Society
  • Taiwan
  • Taxation
  • Technology
  • The ACLU
  • The FairTax
  • The FBI
  • The IRS
  • The President
  • Tyranny
  • United Kingdom
  • United Nations
  • Virginia
  • World Tax


  • LINKS

    Politics/Blogs:
  • Realm of Sovereigns
  • A Republic, if you can keep it
  • American Jury Institute/Fully Informed Jury Association
  • American Sons of Liberty
  • Amy Ridenour's National Center Blog
  • Anglerealm
  • Atlas Blogged
  • Badtux the Snarky Penguin
  • Big Brother Loves You -- Obey Big Brother
  • Black Box Voting
  • Castle Coalition
  • Conservative Punk
  • Constitutional Concepts Foundation
  • Constitution Death Pool
  • Copshots
  • Copwatch
  • David N. Mayer
  • Downsize D.C.
  • Future Musings and Desultory Glances
  • Gateway Pundit
  • GeoBandy
  • Gun Owners of America
  • Historium
  • historyteacher
  • How to Contact Congress or the White House
  • individ
  • Institute for Justice
  • Jack Yoest: War Archives
  • Jake Porter
  • Know Your Land Rights
  • Leaving Babylon
  • Libercontrarian
  • Libertarian Outlook
  • Liberty's Outpost
  • Libertythink
  • Live Free or Die
    -----The 'Civil Flag' -- Forgotten Flag, or Flag of Fraud and Fiction?
  • Mark Gilmore
  • Mike's America
  • Modern Tribalist
  • MoveOff
  • Mythusmage Opines (Old Link)
  • News, the Universe, and Everything
  • Obey
  • Oh, That Liberal Media!
  • Ordering a Pizza Under a National Computerized ID Database
  • Propaganda Matrix
  • ScrappleFace: News Fairly Unbalanced. We Report. You Decipher.
  • Steve's America
  • Tapscott's Copy Desk
  • Technorati (A useful blog search engine)
  • The Asylum
  • The City Troll
  • The FairTax
    -----Status of the 'Fair Tax Act of 2005' (H.R. 25; S 25)
  • The Fountain of Truth
  • The Free State Project
  • The Gun Toting Liberal
  • The Sentinel of Alachua County, Florida
  • Tomato 7
  • Tom’s Fireside Chat
  • TRIMonline
  • Truth in Justice
  • Victims-of-Law

  • Games:
  • Customary Checkers
  • The Basic Rules of Checkers (ACF Approved)
  • Abalone

  • Weights & Measures:
  • Nearly Everything You Need to Know About Weights and Measures
  • The Dozenal Society of Great Britain
  • Footrule

  • Miscellany:
  • Don McAlvany's International Collectors Associates (ICA)
  • The Relative Value of the Dollar (Use this CPI calculator to determine how the value of the current dollar stands up against past dollar values)
  • Writing Help (proofreading, copyediting, and research)
  • Common Errors in English
  • Useful Definitions of Political Terms

  • Charity:
  • AmeriCares
  • International Mission Board
  • Feed the Children
  • World Vision: Building a Better World for Children
  • - - -

    Powered by Blogger

    Anyone is free to comment on this site. Therefore, outgoing links posted by third parties may contain objectional material, but do not reflect the views of this site's owner. When linking to an outside page, links should not direct the reader to nude pictures, erotic stories, or other forms of pornography. Nor should links appear to sites using excessive profanity. Use common sense. If you would be ashamed for your church-going grandmother to see it, you shouldn't link to it. In addition to not linking to any inappropriate material, commenters should watch their language, else their posts will be deleted. Likewise, libelous statements will not be tolerated.

    [Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

    [Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

    [Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]



    Saturday, August 06, 2005

    Was it Necessary for us to Drop the Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima?

    So, the more I read about the circumstances surrounding the war with Japan and the Hiroshima, the more problems I have with some of the things we've been told. Like, for example, that dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima was necessary to win the war. It turns out that it wasn't, in fact, necessary.

    "President Dwight Eisenhower . . . had reservations. In a 1963 interview with Newsweek magazine, he said: 'The Japanese were ready to surrender and it wasn't necessary to hit them with that awful thing.'"

    It is simply not true that the Japanese were unwilling to surrender before the bomb was dropped. "The Japanese had sued for surrender several times during the year before Hiroshima. The Japanese asked for only one condition -- that the Emperor be allowed to remain in place.

    The U.S. refused because FDR had coined the ridiculous phrase 'unconditional surrender' and was determined to stick to it. When the Japanese eventually surrendered without condition, the U.S. allowed the Emperor to remain in place anyway.

    Almost every leading U.S. general and admiral was appalled by Truman's dropping of the atomic bomb -- especially on two cities with no military significance whatsoever."
    ---------'My God, what have we done?' -- the commander of the 'Enola Gay'
    --------- The Myths of World War II
    ---------Hiroshima: Who Disagreed with the Atomic Bombing

    * * *

    The bombing:

    "Thousands of people were instantly carbonised in a blast that was thousands of times hotter than the sun's surface; further from the epicentre, birds ignited in mid-flight, eyeballs popped and internal organs were sucked from bodies of victims.
    By the end of the day an estimated 160,000 were dead or injured and the bomb's "ghosts" walked the city -- thousands of initial survivors who would die within days, often with the word mizu -- water -- on their lips. Many more subsequently died -- and are still dying -- from various cancers."

    _____________________________________________

    5 Comments:
    Blogger David Schantz said...

    I'll be checking out the links. I wanted to let you know I have posted my Question Of The Week (on this subject) I hope you will stop by to answer it.

    God Bless America, God Save The Republic

    8/07/2005 4:26 AM  
    _____________________________________________

    Blogger Michael Morrison said...

    Realm, your comments, both here and at David Schantz' blog, are great, and very necessary balances to the uninformed and usually just emotional comments of people who have not done the studying you have done.
    I thank you for your insight.
    Let me add, please, that as long as governments continue to have the near-ownership of people, of individual human beings, as long as governments continue to hold such power, then future wars and future nuclear destruction will remain not only possible, but likely.

    8/07/2005 1:20 PM  
    _____________________________________________

    Blogger JoeSixPack said...

    Was it necessary for us to Drop the Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima?

    I would like to try and answer that question with a question. Is the purposeful killing of innocent men, women, and children ever justified?

    The word 'terrorist' has often been associated with individuals who have no qualms about killing innocent men, women, and children. Suicide bombers have been getting a lot of negative press of late, but in comparison to the atrocity committed by the U.S. government in Hiroshima it shows the media to be a little lopsided in their reporting.

    How can the U.S. government, in good conscience, wage a 'War on Terror' after being the first and only country to ever inflict mass casualties, using nuclear weapons, on innocent civilians?

    Where does the U.S. government get off throwing stones while living in a glass house? And better yet, where does the U.S. government get off complaining when some of the stones they've been throwing come crashing through the living room window? It doesn't sound like a very responsible plan to me.

    The purposeful killing of innocent men, women, and children, as the U.S. government did in Hiroshima, is terrorism by anyone's definition of the word.

    The U.S. government makes a fool of itself when it proclaims that the taking of approximately 3,000 innocent lives in the World Trade Center attack is 'terrorism' while not owning up to its own terrorist misdeeds in Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

    I would contend the purposeful killing of innocent men, women, and children is wrong...period. That being said, the question of whether it was necessary to do so in Hiroshima becomes a moot point, at least in my opinion.

    8/07/2005 5:29 PM  
    _____________________________________________

    Blogger Chris said...

    I found my way here via Schantz's blog.

    You are very correct with your research and I left a lengthy comment on Schantz's blog concerning my opinions on the matter. Whenever you get some time, check it out.

    My overall conclusion is that had there not been a Pearl Harbor, there would not have been a Hiroshima.

    8/09/2005 12:26 AM  
    _____________________________________________

    Blogger Scriptor said...

    I do know of an attempted coup by some Japanese military units right before the surrender broadcasting,but most of the military were loyal. Also, I read in a book that the ever-tightening U.S. submarine blockade could have ended the itself. After all, it would be hard to fight when your country can barely make anything but small arms.

    Nobody except Truman himself will know exactly why the atomic bomb was dropped. There may have been something else that was covered up, but that sounds too conspiratorial. Also, the bombing of Nagasaki was completely unnecessary. The bomber was supposed to attack a military base, but a little bad weather prevented that, they couldn't even recall the plane.

    8/17/2005 2:40 PM  
    _____________________________________________

    Post a Comment

    Return Home


    * * *

    "If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen."

    --Samuel Adams
    ____________________

    Sovereign Commentary · http://sovrealm.blogspot.com · Copyright © 2004-2007